Cake Mountain Rarity Tier List

This page ranks Cake Mountain cakes by the rarity names FUNgry actually published. Mythical sits in S, Legendary in A, Rare in B. Everything without one of those three tags is treated as unspecialized common farm fuel. We do not invent cake names, flavor lines, or drop percentages. The listing promises hundreds of cakes and says deeper layers run rarer. That is enough to rank keep versus sell, and it is not enough to publish a fake roster.

Use this list while you still have bag space. Keep unique high-tag slices for the plate. Sell duplicates and unspecialized commons to fund spoon and bag upgrades. If you came here from the tier list hub, jump to the game pass ranking after you understand which tags are worth a bag slot.

S tier — Mythical

Mythical is the top named rarity on the Roblox listing. In progression terms it is S because a unique Mythical is the slice you do not sell on first sight. The mountain is an incremental: coins come from selling, but the long-term collection and the plate of favorites are fed by the rarest tags. When a Mythical lands, park it, check whether you already own that look, and only sell a true duplicate.

Deeper digging is the official path toward this tag. This wiki will not pretend a starter spoon on the outer icing has the same Mythical odds as a long session in deeper layers. If you are still filling a small bag on the first visible frosting, you are farming fuel, not hunting S. The rare cake guide covers that depth habit without inventing rates.

Group luck is the one free modifier the listing names. Join FUNgry for the Special Plate plus luck bonus before you spend a session chasing Mythical. That bonus does not turn commons into Mythical on command. It is a listed luck nudge, not a cheat sheet.

A tier — Legendary

Legendary is the middle named rarity and A on this list. It is worth a keep check every time. A first Legendary of a look belongs on the plate or in the index. A second copy is sell pressure unless you are decorating duplicates on purpose. Legendary is not as scarce a headline as Mythical, but it is still not farm fuel. Treat it as the upgrade that proves you left the outer layers.

Because the listing never publishes a Legendary-to-Mythical ratio, this wiki will not invent one. Rank A means: keep uniques, sell extras, and do not empty a bag of Legendaries just because you want a slightly stronger spoon today. Coins from unspecialized commons should buy that spoon first.

B tier — Rare

Rare is the lowest named rarity and B on this list. Rare is still named. That matters. A first Rare of a look is a collection tick. A bag of duplicate Rares is closer to cash than a bag of Mythical uniques. In the early hours, Rare feels exciting because it is the first tag you will see that is not plain farm fuel. Later, Rare becomes the volume tag you sort quickly: unique stays, copy sells.

Do not stall a run because a Rare filled the last bag slot if you are standing on a deeper layer that can still roll Legendary or Mythical. Sell or eat according to the loop in how to play, then return. Bag management lives on bags and eating. The 3x Bag Capacity pass is the Robux answer if Rare volume is the thing that sends you to the seller every minute.

Farm fuel — unspecialized commons

The listing does not give unspecialized cakes a prestige name. This wiki therefore does not put them on S, A, or B. They are farm fuel. You dig them, you fill the bag, you sell them, you buy a stronger spoon and a bigger bag, you go deeper. That loop is the game. Commons are not worthless; they are the coin engine. They are just not plate goals.

If a common is the first time you have seen that look, you may still keep one for the cake collection and for plate decorating. One keeper is a collection choice. Ten copies are a sell. Favorites on the plate are for the slices you want to look at, not for a stack of identical icing.

Keep, sell, and plate rules

Keep the first Mythical, Legendary, or Rare of a look. Keep one common only if you care about completing an index. Sell the rest. Decorate the plate from keepers, not from the bag you are about to cash. The listing teases more cakes and more areas, so leave a little plate space for tags that do not exist yet. Until names are published, sort by the three official rarities and by whether you already own the look.

Cross-check this page with the game pass tier list only after the keep-versus-sell habit is automatic. A 2x Sell Value pass multiplies farm fuel. It does not turn a Mythical unique into something you should vendor. New players who still confuse the two should reread getting started and come back with a full bag to practice the sort.